Concepts of voluntary behaviour in children in Soviet and Western psychology: advantages and limitations
This work is licensed under a Сreative Commons Atribiution - NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0)
Abstract
Background. EF deficit is associated with various disorders, such as autism spectrum disorder (ASD), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and learning disabilities. Improving EF in children has a positive effect on the development of their ability to guess the intentions of others and adherence to social and moral rules of behavior. More importantly, inhibitory control and attention switching are reliable predictors of early academic abilities, that is, mathematical abilities and literacy.
Objective. To compare the concepts of voluntary behavior in children in Western psychology with the concepts of conscious action developed in Soviet psychology within the tradition of L.S. Vygotsky and A.R. Luria, and to analyze the advantages and disadvantages of both approaches.
Methods. Review and the comparative analysis of studies.
Results. The theoretical foundations of Western studies of the executive function (EF) are considered in comparison with the studies of “conscious action” conducted within the Vygotsky-Luria’s school. The advantages and limitations of each approach are revealed and the possibilities of applying these approaches to the formation of critical thinking and creative independence in children are shown.
Conclusions. Cognitive models of EF, focused on neurochemical intervention in the correction of executive activity, and the model of voluntary behaviour as “conscious action”, which emphasizes the use of higher mental functions for such correction, are not alternative to each other but complement each other. Only an analysis of specific parameters of violations of voluntariness of action and patterns of integration (or lack thereof) between action, intellect, language, memory and other mental functions can determine which of the above models is best suited for a particular case.
References
Al-Namlah, A. S., Fernyhough, C., Meins, E. (2006). Sociocultural influences on the development of verbal mediation: Private speech and phonological recoding in Saudi Arabian and British samples. Developmental Psychology, (42), 117–131.
Barkley, R. A. (1995). Linkages between attention and executive function. In: G.R. Lyon, N.A. Krasnegor (Eds.), Attention, memory, and executive function. Baltimore, MD: Brookes Publishing Co.
Barkley, R. A., DuPaul, G. J., & Costello, A. (1993) Stimulants. In: J.S. Werry, M.G. Aman (Eds.). Practitioners guide to psychoactive drugs for children and adolescents (pp. 205–237). New York: Plenum.
Benson, J.E., & Sabbagh, M.A. (2010). Theory of mind and executive functioning: A developmental neuropsychological approach. In: P.D. Zelazo, M. Chandler, E. Crone (Eds). Developmental social cognitive neuroscience (pp. 63–80). New York: Psychology Press.
Bialystok, E., Martin, M. (2003). Notation to symbol: Development in children’s understanding of print. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, (86), 223–243.
Blair, C. Razza, R.P. (2007). Relating effortful control, executive function, and false belief understanding to emerging math and literacy ability in kindergarten. Child Development, (78), 647–663.
Brooks, P.J., Hanauer, J.B., Padowska, B., Rosman, H. (2003). The role of selective attention in preschooler’s rule use in a novel dimensional card sort. Cognitive Development, (18), 195–215.
Bruce, S., Zayyad, M. (2009). The Development of Object Permanence in Children with Intellectual Disability, Physical Disability, Autism, and Blindness. International Journal of Disability, Development and Education, (56), 229–246.
Carlson, S.M., Moses, L.J., Hix, H.R. (1988). The role of inhibitory processes in young children’s difficulties with deception and false belief. Child Development, 69(3), 672–691.
Cepeda, N.J., Kramer, A.F., Gonzalez de Sather, J.S.M. (2001). Changes in executive control across life span: Examination of task-switching performance. Developmental Psychology, 37(5), 715–730.
Dansen, P., Heron, A. (2012). Cross-cultural tests of Piaget’s theory. URL: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/342242777_Dasen_P_R_Heron_A_1981_Cross-cultural_tests_of_Pi... (accessed: 20.09.2025).
Deák, G.O. (2000). The growth of flexible problem solving: Preschool children use changing verbal cues to infer multiple word meanings. Journal of Cognition and Development, (1), 157–191.
Denckla, M.B., Reiss, A.L. (1997). Prefrontal-subcortical circuits in developmental disorders. In: N.A. Krasnegor, G.R. Lyon, P.S. Goldman-Rakic (Eds.). Development of the prefrontal cortex: Evolution, neurobiology, and behavior (pp. 283–293). Baltimore: Brookes.
Eisenberger, R., Haskins, F., Gambleton, P. (1999). Promised reward and creativity: effects of prior experience. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, (35), 308–325.
Feldman, R. (2009). The development of regulatory functions from birth to 5 years: Insights from premature infants. Child Development, (2), 544-561.
Fernyhough, C., Fradley, E. (2005). Private speech on an executive task:Relations with task difficulty and task performance. Cognitive Development, (20), 103–120.
Frye, D., Zelazo, P. D., Palfai, T. (1995). Theory of mind and rule-based reasoning. Cognitive Development, (10), 483–527.
Gaskins, I.W., Satlow, E. & Pressley, M. (2007). Executive control of reading comprehension in the elementary school. In: L. Meltzer (Ed.), Executive Function in Education. From theory to practice (pp. 194–215). New York: The Guilford Press.
Graham, S., Harris, K.R., Olinghouse, N. (2007). Addressing executive function problems in writing: An example from the Self-Regulated Strategy development model. In: L. Meltzer (Ed.), Executive Function in Education. From theory to practice (pp. 216–235). New York: The Guilford Press.
Grant, D.A., Berg, E. (1948). A behavioral analysis of degree of reinforcement and ease of shifting to new responses in Weigl-type card-sorting problem. Journal of Experimental Psychology, (38), 404–411.
Hongwanishkul, D., Happaney, K.R., Lee, W.S.C., Zelazo, P.H. (2005). Assessment of hot and cool executive function in young children: Age-related changes and individual differences. Developmental Neuropsychology, (28), 617–644.
Hughes, C. (1998). Executive function in preschoolers: Links with theory of mind and verbal ability. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, (16), 233–253.
Kahn, James V. (1976). Utility of the uzgiris and hunt scales of sensorimotor development with severely and profoundly retarded children. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, (6), 663–665.
Kochanska, G., Murray, K., Jacques, T.Y, Koenig, A.L., Vandergeest, K.A. (1996). Inhibitory control in young children and its role in emerging internalization. Child Development, (67), 490–507.
Kwon, Y.I. (2002). Western influences in Korean preschool education. International Educational Journal, (3), 153–164.
Luria, A.R. (1970). Human brain and psychological processes. Neuropsychological analysis of conscious activity. Moscow: Pedagogika Publ. (In Russ.).
Luria, A.R. (1980). Higher cortical functions in man. New York: Basic books.
Luria, A.R. (Ed.) (1958). Problems of the higher neural activity of normal and abnormal child. Vol. 1. Moscow: Academy of Pedagogical Sciences Publ. (In Russ.).
Luria, A.R., Subbotsky, E.V. (1972). Investigations into the development of a conscious action. Report 3. Novye Issledovaniya v Psikhologii i Vozrastnoi Fiziologii = New Investigations in Psychology and Age Physiology, (2), 22–27. (In Russ.).
Luria, A.R., Subbotsky, E.V. (1978). Zur fruhen Ontogeneze der steuerden Funktion der Sprache Die Psychologie des 20 Jahrhunderts. Zurich: KinderVerlag.
Moses, L.J. (2001). Executive accounts of Theory-of-Mind development. Child Development, 72(3), 688–690.
Mouchiroud, C., Lubart, T. (2001). Children’s original thinking: an empirical examination of alternative measures derived from divergent thinking tasks. The Journal of Genetic Psychology, (162), 382–401.
Oh, S., Lewis, C. (2008). Korean preschoolers’ advanced inhibitory control and its relation to other executive skills and mental state understanding. Child Development, (1), 80–99.
Prencipe, A., Zelazo, P.D. (2005). Development of affective decision-making for self and other: Evidence for the integration of first— and third-person perspectives. Psychological Science, (16), 501–505.
Roditi, B.N., Steinberg, J. (2007). The strategic math classroom: Executive function process and mathematics learning. In: L. Meltzer (Ed.), Executive function in education. From theory to practice (pp. 237–260). New York: The Guilford Press.
Russ, S.W., Kaugars, A.S. (2001). Emotion in children’s play and creative problem solving. Creativity Research Journal, (13), 211–219.
Russ, S.W., Robins, A.L., Christiano, B.A. (1999) Pretend play: longitudinal prediction of creativity and affect in fantasy in children. Creativity Research Journal, (12), 129–139.
Sabbagh, M., Xu, F., Carlson, S.M., Moses, L.J., Lee, K. (2006). The development of executive functioning and theory of mind: A comparison of Chinese and U.S. preschoolers. Psychological Science, (17), 74–81.
Sabbagh, M.A., Moses, L.J., Shiverick, S. (2006). Executive functioning and preschoolers’ understanding of false beliphotographs, and false signs. Child Development, (4), 1034–1049.
Smith, G.J.W. (2005). How should creativity be defined? Creativity Research Journal, (17), 293–295.
Subbotsky, E.V. (1981). Genesis of personality behaviour in preschoolers and style of communication. Voprosy Psikhologii = Issues of Psychology, (2), 68–78. (In Russ.).
Subbotsky, E.V. (1976). Psychology of partnership relationships in preschoolers. Moscow: University Publ.
Subbotsky, E.V. (1993). The birth of personality. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
Vygotsky, L. (1983). The problem of mental retardation. (In Russ.). URL: https://mybook.ru/author/lev-semenovich-vygotskij/problema-umstvennoj-otstalosti/read (accessed: 20.07.2025)
Welsh, M.C., Pennington, B.F. (1988). Assessing frontal lobe functioning in children: Views from developmental psychology. Developmental Neuropsychology, (4), 199–230.
Wigal, S.B. (2009). Efficacy and safety limitations of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder pharmacotherapy in children and adults. CNS Drugs, 23, Suppl 1, 21–31.
Wright, I., Lewis, V., Collis, G.M. (June 2006). Imitation and representational development in young children with down syndrome. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, (24), 429–450.
Yerys, B.E. Munakata, Y. (2006). When labels hurt but novelty helps: Children’s perseveration and flexibility in a card-sorting task. Child Development, (77), 15–89, 1607.
Zelazo, P. D., Müller, U. (2002). Executive function in typical and atypical development. In: U. Goswami (Ed.), Handbook of childhood cognitive development (pp. 445–469). Oxford: Blackwell.
Zelazo, P.D., Muller, U., Frye, D., Marcovitch, S. (2003). The development of executive function in early childhood. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 68(3).